According to research on the comparative effectiveness of psychotherapeutic techniques, which statement best reflects current scientific consensus?
A
Cognitive-behavioral therapy is significantly more effective than all other forms of psychotherapy for every disorder.
B
Humanistic therapies consistently outperform behavioral therapies in treating anxiety disorders.
C
Most major psychotherapeutic approaches produce similar outcomes for most psychological disorders.
D
Only psychodynamic therapy has been shown to be effective in controlled research studies.
0 댓글
검증된 단계별 안내
1
Step 1: Understand the context of the question, which is about the comparative effectiveness of different psychotherapeutic techniques based on current scientific research.
Step 2: Recognize that research in psychotherapy often compares outcomes across various therapeutic approaches, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), humanistic therapies, behavioral therapies, and psychodynamic therapy.
Step 3: Recall the 'Dodo bird verdict' in psychotherapy research, which suggests that most major psychotherapeutic approaches tend to produce similar outcomes for a wide range of psychological disorders, rather than one being universally superior.
Step 4: Evaluate each statement in the problem by comparing it to this consensus: CBT is not significantly more effective than all others for every disorder; humanistic therapies do not consistently outperform behavioral therapies for anxiety; psychodynamic therapy is not the only effective approach.
Step 5: Conclude that the statement reflecting the scientific consensus is that most major psychotherapeutic approaches produce similar outcomes for most psychological disorders.