Skip to main content
뒤로

Oligopoly: Strategic Behavior, Cartels, and Game Theory

스터디 가이드 - 스마트 노트

자료에 맞춘 맞춤형 노트, 핵심 정의, 예시, 맥락을 확장해 제공합니다.

Chapter 17: Oligopoly

Overview

This chapter explores the structure and behavior of oligopolistic markets, where a few large firms dominate and strategic interdependence shapes outcomes. Key topics include market concentration, collusion, game theory, the prisoner's dilemma, and public policy responses.

Measuring Market Concentration

The Four-Firm Concentration Ratio (CR4)

  • Definition: The percentage of total industry sales/output accounted for by the four largest firms.

  • Interpretation:

    • CR4 < 40%: Competitive or Monopolistically Competitive market.

    • CR4 ≥ 50%–60%: Oligopoly (dominated by a small handful of strategic giants).

Industry

CR4

Dominant Market Players

Video Game Consoles

100%

Sony PlayStation, Microsoft Xbox, Nintendo

Smartphone Operating Systems

~99%

Google Android, Apple iOS

Vietnam Mobile Telecom

~95%

Viettel, Vinaphone (VNPT), MobiFone

Vietnam Ride-Hailing

~90%

Grab, Xanh SM, Be

Economic Driver: Massive economies of scale, network externalities, and high infrastructure capital make oligopolies prevalent in modern tech and communications.

CR4 concentration ratio table and examples

Strategic Interdependence & Game Theory

Strategic Interdependence

  • Oligopoly: A market structure with only a few sellers offering similar or identical products.

  • Essence of Strategy: In competition or monopoly, firms ignore rivals. In oligopoly, each firm's profit depends directly on rivals' actions.

  • The Chessboard: Every price change, ad spend, or capacity expansion triggers an immediate rival countermove.

Game Theory: The Toolkit

  • Definition: The formal mathematical study of how rational decision-makers behave in strategic situations.

  • John Nash (1994 Nobel): Formalized the concept of equilibrium in non-cooperative games.

  • Universal Relevance: Used in business pricing, corporate takeovers, military strategy, diplomacy, and auction design.

Strategic Interdependence and Game Theory summary

The Duopoly Model: Setting the Stage

Duopoly is the simplest form of oligopoly, with only two firms. The model illustrates how firms' decisions affect market outcomes.

Price (P)

Market Q

Total Revenue

Total Cost

Total Industry Profit

$45

50

$2,250

$500

$1,750

$40

60

$2,400

$600

$1,800 (MONOPOLY MAX!)

$35

70

$2,450

$700

$1,750

$30

80

$2,400

$800

$1,600

$10 (MC)

120

$1,200

$1,200

$0 (COMPETITIVE!)

Key Point: The duopoly outcome lies between the competitive (P = MC) and monopoly (P > MC) extremes.

Duopoly model table

Collusion and Cartels: The Monopoly Dream

The Perfect Collusion Scenario

  • Collusion: An agreement among firms over quantities to produce or prices to charge.

  • Cartel: A formal group of firms coordinating like a single monopoly.

  • Profit Split Example: Restrict combined Q = 60 at P = $40. Each firm produces 30, earning $900 profit. Total profit = $1,800 (maximum possible).

Why Cartels Break Down

  • Antitrust Laws: Explicit cartels and price-fixing are illegal criminal conspiracies in most countries.

  • Incentive to Cheat: Once the price is high, each firm has a massive unilateral temptation to secretly produce more and earn more profit.

  • Real-World Example: OPEC (oil) struggles with member states cheating on production quotas.

Collusion and Cartels explanation

The Temptation to Cheat: Self-Interest vs. Cooperation

Even when firms agree to collude, individual incentives often lead to cheating, undermining the cartel.

  • The Cheater's Calculation: If one firm secretly increases output, it can gain at the other's expense.

  • Market Outcome if One Cheats:

    • Total Output: Q = 70 plans

    • Market Price: Falls to P = $35/plan

    • Total Profit: Falls from $1,800 to $1,750

  • Payoff Divergence:

    • Cheater: Profit rises to $1,000

    • Faithful: Profit falls to $750

Cheating in cartels and payoff divergence

The Breakdown of the Cartel: Nash Equilibrium

When both firms cheat, the cartel collapses to a Nash Equilibrium, where neither can improve their outcome by changing strategy alone.

  • Both Firms Cheat: Q = 80, P = $30, Profit = $800 each.

  • Further Cheating: If one expands further, profit drops even more (defection does not pay).

  • Nash Equilibrium: Each chooses their best strategy given the other's choice; mutual cheating is stable but suboptimal.

Nash Equilibrium in cartel breakdown

Comparing Market Outcomes: The Spectrum of Power

  • Market Quantity Spectrum: Monopoly (Q = 60) < Oligopoly (Q = 80) < Competition (Q = 120)

  • Market Price Spectrum: Competition (P = $10) < Oligopoly (P = $30) < Monopoly (P = $40)

  • Social Welfare Trade-Off: Society is better off than under monopoly, but worse off than under perfect competition.

Market spectrum: monopoly, oligopoly, competition

The Output Effect vs. Price Effect in Oligopoly

Oligopolists face two opposing effects when deciding whether to expand output by one unit.

  • The Output Effect (+): Selling one more unit at a price above marginal cost increases total profit.

  • The Price Effect (–): Raising total output lowers market price, reducing revenue on all units sold.

  • Why Oligopolists Expand More Than Monopolists: A monopolist bears the full price effect; an oligopolist bears only a fraction. As the number of sellers rises, the price effect falls, and the market outcome approaches perfect competition.

Output effect vs price effect in oligopoly

Introduction to Game Theory: The Payoff Matrix

The payoff matrix is a tool for analyzing strategic choices in oligopoly and other games.

Firm A \ Firm B

Produce 30 (Cooperate)

Produce 40 (Cheat)

Produce 30 (Cooperate)

Firm A: $900 Firm B: $900

Firm A: $750 Firm B: $1,000

Produce 40 (Cheat)

Firm A: $1,000 Firm B: $750

Firm A: $800 Firm B: $800 (NASH EQUILIBRIUM)

How to Read: Each cell shows the payoffs to both players. To solve, isolate one player at a time and determine their best response to each rival's choice.

Payoff matrix for duopoly

Dominant Strategy & The Prisoner's Dilemma

The prisoner's dilemma illustrates why rational self-interest can prevent cooperation, even when it is mutually beneficial.

Bonnie \ Clyde

Confess (Betray)

Silent (Cooperate)

Confess (Betray)

Bonnie: 8 yrs Clyde: 8 yrs (NASH EQUILIBRIUM)

Bonnie: Goes Free Clyde: 20 yrs

Silent (Cooperate)

Bonnie: 20 yrs Clyde: Goes Free

Bonnie: 1 yr Clyde: 1 yr (COOPERATIVE OPTIMUM)

Tragic Paradox: Both players have a dominant strategy to confess, resulting in a worse outcome than mutual cooperation.

Prisoner's Dilemma payoff matrix

Active Learning: The Ride-Hailing Promo War

Example: Grab vs. Xanh SM competing for passengers. Each chooses between an aggressive promo campaign or standard pricing.

Grab \ Xanh SM

Run Promos (Aggressive)

Standard Price

Run Promos (Aggressive)

Grab: 15B VND Xanh SM: 15B VND

Grab: 35B VND Xanh SM: 5B VND

Standard Price

Grab: 5B VND Xanh SM: 35B VND

Grab: 25B VND Xanh SM: 25B VND

Task: Find each firm's dominant strategy and the Nash Equilibrium.

Ride-hailing promo war payoff matrix

Active Learning: Solution & Real-World Insight

  • Dominant Strategies: Both firms' best choice is to run promos, regardless of the rival's action.

  • Nash Equilibrium: Both run aggressive promos (15B, 15B VND weekly). Mutual distrust trap: neither dares stop first.

  • Consumer Welfare: Consumers benefit from cheap rides and discounts, but firms earn less profit.

Solution to ride-hailing promo war

Why People Sometimes Cooperate: Repeated Games

  • One-Shot Game: Cheating/defecting is strictly dominant; mutual betrayal is the inevitable Nash Equilibrium.

  • Repeated Game: Firms interact week after week for years. Cheating today brings quick gain, but triggers retaliation tomorrow.

  • Cooperative Strategies:

    • Grim Trigger: "If you cheat once, I will slash prices to competitive levels and punish you forever."

    • Tit-for-Tat: Start by cooperating; in subsequent rounds, do whatever your rival did in the previous round (reward, punish, forgive).

Robert Axelrod's Tournament: In computer simulations, Tit-for-Tat beat all greedy strategies, fostering tacit collusion without illegal secret meetings.

Repeated games and cooperation

Public Policy Toward Oligopolies

Antitrust & Competition Laws

  • Mission: Prevent oligopolies from colluding to act like monopolies (protect consumer welfare).

  • Legal Frameworks:

    • USA: Sherman Act (1890), Clayton Act (1914)

    • Vietnam: Law on Competition (2018)

  • Prohibited Actions: Explicit price fixing, market sharing, bid rigging, and anti-competitive mergers.

Case Study: The Infamous 1982 Phone Call

  • Robert Crandall (American Airlines) called Howard Putnam (Braniff Airlines): "Raise your fares 20 percent. I'll raise mine the next morning... You'll make more money, and I will, too."

  • Putnam taped the call and reported it to the US Department of Justice.

  • Legal Reality: Price fixing is elevated from an unenforceable contract to a criminal conspiracy!

Antitrust laws and infamous phone call

Controversies Over Antitrust Enforcement

  • Resale Price Maintenance: Manufacturer requires retailers not to sell below a set minimum price. Suspicion: Retail price fixing cartel.

  • Predatory Pricing: Large firm cuts prices below cost to drive smaller competitors bankrupt, aiming to raise prices later. Suspicion: Monopolization attempt.

  • Tying & Bundling: Selling two distinct goods bundled together for a single combined price. Suspicion: Leveraging monopoly power across markets.

Economic Debate: Practices that appear anti-competitive on the surface often have legitimate economic rationales that enhance market efficiency and consumer service.

Antitrust enforcement controversies

Pearson Logo

스터디 프렙