BackNatural Selection and Evidence of Evolution: Study Guide Notes
Study Guide - Smart Notes
Tailored notes based on your materials, expanded with key definitions, examples, and context.
Natural Selection and the History of Evolutionary Thought
The Scientists and Their Contributions
This section reviews key historical figures in evolutionary biology and their major ideas, providing context for the development of the theory of evolution by natural selection.
Aristotle: Proposed that species are fixed and unchanging, each designed for a specific purpose by a divine creator. He described a hierarchical "scale of nature," with simple organisms at the bottom and humans at the top. Example: Giraffes have long necks because they were made that way and always have been.
Jean-Baptiste de Lamarck: First to propose a formal hypothesis of evolution. Suggested the inheritance of acquired characteristics: traits acquired during an individual's lifetime (e.g., stretched necks in giraffes) are passed to offspring. Also believed evolution was progressive toward greater complexity. Note: This mechanism is now considered incorrect; only heritable (genetic) variation is passed to offspring.
Charles Darwin: Developed the theory of natural selection after observations during the HMS Beagle voyage. Proposed that individuals with certain heritable traits are more likely to survive and reproduce, leading to changes in populations over time (descent with modification). Defined key concepts of biological fitness and adaptation.
Alfred Russel Wallace: Independently developed a theory of natural selection similar to Darwin's. Both presented their ideas jointly in 1858.
Georges Cuvier: Founder of paleontology. Noted that older fossils differ more from modern species and provided early evidence for extinction. Supported catastrophism (sudden events cause changes), not evolution.
James Hutton: Proposed gradualism: large-scale geological changes result from slow, continuous processes. Influenced Darwin's thinking about slow biological change.
Key Concepts in Natural Selection
Biological Fitness
Biological fitness is the relative ability of an individual to produce surviving offspring compared to others in the same population. It is always a comparison within a population, not between species or between an individual and its environment.
Definition: The number of surviving offspring an individual leaves relative to others.
Example: A giraffe that produces more surviving offspring than others in its population is considered more fit.
Adaptive Traits and Fitness
An adaptation (or adaptive trait) is a heritable trait that increases an individual's fitness in a specific environment. Adaptations are traits (nouns), not processes.
Relationship to fitness: Adaptive traits provide a survival or reproductive advantage, making them more common in the population over time.
Environmental dependence: The value of an adaptation depends on the environment. Example: White fur is adaptive for polar bears in snowy environments but not in forests.
Darwin & Wallace's Four Components of Natural Selection
Although not explicitly listed, these are the core principles of natural selection:
Variation: Individuals in a population vary in their traits.
Heritability: Some of these variations are heritable (passed from parents to offspring).
Overproduction: More offspring are produced than can survive, leading to competition.
Differential Survival and Reproduction: Individuals with advantageous traits are more likely to survive and reproduce, passing those traits to the next generation.
Conclusion: Over time, adaptive traits accumulate in the population, leading to evolution. Example: The peppered moth color morphs shifted in frequency during the Industrial Revolution due to changes in tree bark color.
Important distinction: Individuals do not evolve; populations evolve. Natural selection acts on individuals, but evolution is observed as changes in trait frequencies in populations.
Natural selection vs. evolution: Natural selection is the mechanism; evolution is the observed change.
Evidence of Evolution
Extant vs. Extinct
Extant: Species that are still alive today.
Extinct: Species that no longer exist.
Example: Fossils that do not match any extant species suggest extinction has occurred.
Vestigial Traits
A vestigial trait is a structure with little or no function in a species but is homologous to a functional trait in a related species. Vestigial traits are remnants of ancestral features.
Examples: Human tailbone (coccyx), goosebumps, wisdom teeth, whale hip bones.
Significance: Vestigial traits are expected if species share common ancestry.
Transitional Traits and Species
A transitional species has traits intermediate between ancestral and descendant species. A transitional trait is an intermediate form of a specific structure.
Example: Fossils in the whale lineage show both ancestral (fins, scales) and derived (flat head, eyes on top) traits, bridging the gap between land mammals and modern whales.
Homologous Traits
Homology refers to similarities between species due to shared ancestry. Homologous traits are inherited from a common ancestor.
Significance: Homologies provide evidence for relatedness among species.
Analogous Traits and Convergent Evolution
Analogous traits are similarities due to shared function or environment, not shared ancestry. Convergent evolution is the process by which unrelated species independently evolve similar traits.
Examples: Dolphins (mammals), sharks (fish), and ichthyosaurs (reptiles) all have streamlined bodies for swimming, but do not share a recent common ancestor with that body plan. Sugar gliders and flying squirrels both have gliding membranes but are only distantly related.
Key point: Not all similarities are due to homology; some arise independently due to similar selective pressures.
Atavism / Atavistic Traits
An atavism is the reappearance of an ancestral trait that had been lost in a species' evolutionary history. The genetic instructions for the trait are usually present but inactive, and may be reactivated in rare cases.
Examples: Humans born with tails; whales with extra hind-limb structures.
Difference from vestigial traits: Vestigial traits are reduced structures present in all individuals of a species; atavisms are rare, unexpected reappearances of ancestral features.
Co-opted Traits (Exaptation)
A trait is co-opted (or exapted) when a structure that evolved for one function is later repurposed for a different function.
Example: Feathers in birds likely evolved first for insulation or display in dinosaurs, and were later co-opted for flight.
Practice Questions and Applications
Fitness: Defined as the relative ability to leave surviving offspring.
Adaptation: A trait favored by natural selection because it increases fitness in the current environment.
Lamarck vs. Darwin on white fur in polar bears: Lamarck: Acquired during life and passed on; Darwin: Individuals with lighter fur survived better and reproduced more.
Fitness and adaptation: Adaptation is the trait; fitness is the reproductive advantage it provides.
Peppered moth example: Natural selection is the process; evolution is the population-level change in trait frequency.
Vestigial wings in flightless birds: Yes, these are vestigial traits.
Flying squirrels' closest relatives: Other mammals (e.g., rodents), not sugar gliders; similarity to sugar gliders is due to convergent evolution (analogous traits).