Speciation: Concepts, Mechanisms, and Processes

Speciation

Introduction to Speciation

Speciation is the evolutionary process by which populations evolve to become distinct species. It is a fundamental concept in biology, explaining the diversity of life forms on Earth. The process involves the development of reproductive isolation between populations, leading to the formation of new species.

• Species: An evolutionarily independent population or group of populations.

• Speciation is ongoing and can be observed in various organisms, such as the diverse cichlid fish species shown in the provided image.

Defining and Identifying Species

Species Concepts

Biologists use several criteria to define and identify species. The three most commonly used concepts are:

1. Biological species concept

2. Morphological species (morphospecies) concept

3. Phylogenetic species concept

The Biological Species Concept

Reproductive Isolation as a Criterion

The biological species concept defines species based on reproductive isolation. According to this concept, species are groups of actually or potentially interbreeding natural populations that are reproductively isolated from other such groups.

• Reproductive isolation results in a lack of gene flow between populations.

• Members of different populations do not interbreed, or if they do, they fail to produce viable, fertile offspring.

Mechanisms of Reproductive Isolation

• Prezygotic isolation: Individuals of different species are prevented from mating successfully.

• Postzygotic isolation: Hybrid offspring do not survive or reproduce.

Types of Reproductive Isolation

Type	Prezygotic Isolation	Postzygotic Isolation
Habitat	Populations are isolated because they breed in different habitats. Example: Mainland mice and beach mice mate in different habitats.
Behavioral	Populations do not interbreed because they have different courtship displays. Example: Male songbirds sing species-specific songs to attract females.
Mechanical	Mating fails because male and female reproductive structures are incompatible. Example: The genital structures of some male and female insects fit together like a "lock and key" system.
Gametic barrier	Mating fails because eggs and sperm are incompatible. Example: Differences in the binding protein determine whether sea urchin sperm can penetrate eggs.
Hybrid inviability		Hybrid offspring do not develop normally and die at some point during early development. Example: When ring-necked doves mate with rock doves, less than 6 percent of eggs hatch.
Hybrid sterility		Hybrid offspring mature but are sterile as adults. Example: Horses and donkeys can mate to produce mules, which are sterile.

Limitations of the Biological Species Concept

• Reproductive isolation cannot be evaluated in fossil species or species that reproduce asexually.

• Cannot be applied to populations that do not overlap geographically (allopatric populations).

The Morphological Species Concept

Definition and Application

The morphological species concept identifies species based on differences in size, shape, or other morphological features. It is widely applicable, especially when data on gene flow are unavailable.

• Useful for classifying fossil species and species that reproduce asexually.

• Equally applicable to both sexual and asexual organisms.

Limitations of the Morphological Species Concept

• Polymorphic species may be classified as more than one species.

• Cannot identify cryptic species that differ in non-morphological traits.

• The features used to distinguish species are often subjective.

The Phylogenetic Species Concept

Definition and Application

The phylogenetic species concept identifies species based on evolutionary history. It relies on the idea that all species are related by common ancestry and that a species is the smallest monophyletic group on a phylogenetic tree.

• Monophyletic group: Consists of an ancestral population plus all of its descendants.

• Identified by synapomorphies (shared, derived traits unique to a group).

• Can be applied to any type of population (sexual, asexual, fossil).

Advantages and Limitations

• Logical because different species have different synapomorphies due to lack of gene flow and independent evolution.

• Phylogenies are currently available for only a small subset of populations.

• May lead to recognition of many more species than other concepts.

Summary Table: Comparison of Species Concepts

Species Concept	Definition	Advantages	Limitations
Biological	Species are groups of interbreeding populations reproductively isolated from others.	Directly relates to gene flow and reproductive isolation.	Not applicable to fossils, asexual organisms, or allopatric populations.
Morphological	Species are identified by morphological differences.	Widely applicable; useful for fossils and asexual species.	Subjective; cannot distinguish cryptic species; issues with polymorphism.
Phylogenetic	Species are the smallest monophyletic groups on a phylogenetic tree.	Applicable to all organisms; based on evolutionary history.	Requires detailed phylogenies; may recognize many more species.

Key Terms

• Species: Evolutionarily independent group of organisms.

• Reproductive isolation: Barriers that prevent gene flow between populations.

• Prezygotic isolation: Barriers that prevent mating or fertilization.

• Postzygotic isolation: Barriers that prevent hybrid offspring from surviving or reproducing.

• Monophyletic group: A group consisting of an ancestor and all its descendants.

• Synapomorphy: A shared, derived trait unique to a group.

Additional info: The provided images and notes focus on the mechanisms and concepts of speciation, particularly the criteria for defining species and the types of reproductive isolation. The cichlid fish image exemplifies ongoing speciation and diversity within a lineage.