A student, when solving the following 'predict-the-product' question, made a common mistake by writing the answer shown here. Explain why this reaction would not work as written.

Mullins 1st Edition
Ch. 17 - Carbonyl Addition Reactions: Aldehydes and Ketones
Problema 12aClassify the following nucleophiles as strong, weak, or intermediate. Would you expect each to add to a carbonyl directly or wait for a carbocation to form?
(a) 
Guida verificata passo dopo passo
Risposta video verificata per un problema simile:
Concetti chiave
Nucleophilicity
Carbonyl Compounds
Carbocation Formation
Identify the bonds broken and formed in the following addition reaction.
(a) Would you expect this reaction to be favored based on entropy?
(b) Based on enthalpy [qualitatively]?
(c) Overall?
Another way the preceding might be presented is to say that the minor resonance structure(s) reveal the reactivity of a molecule. Show how the minor resonance structure(s) can help us understand that the following reactions occur with the regioselectivity shown.
(a)
(b)
(c)
Classify the following nucleophiles as strong, weak, or intermediate. Would you expect each to add to a carbonyl directly or wait for a carbocation to form?
(d)
Predict the reagents or reactant(s) necessary to complete the following syntheses.
(c)
Classify the following nucleophiles as strong, weak, or intermediate. Would you expect each to add to a carbonyl directly or wait for a carbocation to form?
b)