Skip to main content
Pearson+ LogoPearson+ Logo
Ch. 22 - Evolution by Natural Selection
Freeman - Biological Science 7th Edition
Freeman7th EditionBiological ScienceISBN: 9783584863285Not the one you use?Change textbook
Chapter 22, Problem 11

Most mice living on the mainland of Florida are brown, but the mice that live on the sand dunes of the barrier islands have white fur. The differences in color are heritable, determined by genes such as MC1R. It is intuitive that the light color of beach-dwelling mice is an adaptation for blending into their environment—and thus evading predators.Compare how evolution by inheritance of acquired characters and the theory of evolution by natural selection would explain the observation of white mice living primarily on light soil and brown mice living primarily on dark soil.

Verified step by step guidance
1
Identify the two theories to compare: inheritance of acquired characters and natural selection. The inheritance of acquired characters suggests that traits developed during an organism's life can be passed on to its offspring. In contrast, natural selection posits that individuals with traits better suited to their environment are more likely to survive and reproduce, passing those advantageous traits to the next generation.
Apply the theory of inheritance of acquired characters to the scenario: According to this theory, if the mainland brown mice moved to the sandy islands and gradually acquired lighter fur to blend in with the sand for better survival against predators, they would then pass this acquired white fur trait to their offspring.
Apply the theory of natural selection to the scenario: In this theory, among the mice population, some might have had mutations leading to lighter fur. These lighter-furred mice, when living on the sandy islands, would have been less visible to predators compared to their darker-furred counterparts. Over time, these white mice would have a higher survival rate and reproduce more, leading to a predominance of white fur in the population.
Compare the genetic basis in both theories: The inheritance of acquired characters does not necessarily involve genetic changes or mutations, whereas natural selection relies on genetic variations (like mutations in the MC1R gene) that confer a survival advantage being passed down through generations.
Evaluate the plausibility of each theory based on modern genetic understanding: Modern genetics supports the theory of natural selection, where genetic mutations that enhance survival are selected for over generations. The inheritance of acquired characters, lacking a mechanism for genetic alteration through personal experience, is not supported by current genetic evidence.

Verified video answer for a similar problem:

This video solution was recommended by our tutors as helpful for the problem above.
Video duration:
2m
Was this helpful?

Key Concepts

Here are the essential concepts you must grasp in order to answer the question correctly.

Evolution by Inheritance of Acquired Characters

This theory, proposed by Lamarck, suggests that organisms can pass on traits acquired during their lifetime to their offspring. For example, if a mouse were to develop a lighter fur color due to environmental factors, this trait could be inherited by its descendants. However, this concept has largely been discredited in favor of genetic inheritance, as it does not adequately explain the mechanisms of evolution observed in nature.
Recommended video:
04:39
Lamarck and Inheritance of Acquired Traits

Natural Selection

Natural selection, a key mechanism of evolution proposed by Darwin, posits that individuals with traits better suited to their environment are more likely to survive and reproduce. In the case of the mice, those with lighter fur in sandy environments are less visible to predators, increasing their chances of survival and passing on their genes. This process leads to the gradual adaptation of populations to their specific habitats.
Recommended video:
04:43
Natural Selection

Genetic Variation and Heritability

Genetic variation refers to the differences in DNA among individuals, which can lead to variations in traits such as fur color. Heritability is the proportion of observed variation in a trait that can be attributed to genetic factors. In the context of the mice, the heritable trait of fur color, influenced by genes like MC1R, allows for the adaptation of populations to their environments through natural selection, as advantageous traits are passed down through generations.
Recommended video:
02:16
Sources of Genetic Variation
Related Practice
Textbook Question
Explain why the overprescription of antibiotics by doctors, or the overuse of everyday soaps containing antibiotics, can be a health risk.
1097
views
Textbook Question

Coral reefs are biodiverse ecosystems that provide food, income, coastal protection, and many other services to millions of people. Yet coral reefs are under threat from human impacts such as climate change—many corals cannot tolerate the warming ocean water and have suffered massive 'bleaching' events, which can be fatal. Researchers have discovered that some corals have the capacity to acclimatize to warmer water, while other corals do not. The researchers fear that because corals are long-lived colonial animals and thus evolve slowly, they may not be able to adapt to global warming fast enough to avoid extinction. Explain how the difference between acclimatize and adapt is important to the fate of corals.

899
views
Textbook Question

The geneticist James Crow wrote that successful scientific theories have the following characteristics: (1) They explain otherwise puzzling observations; (2) they provide connections between otherwise disparate observations; (3) they make predictions that can be tested; and (4) they are heuristic, meaning that they open up new avenues of theory and experimentation. Crow added two other elements of scientific theories that he considered important on a personal, emotional level: (5) They should be elegant, in the sense of being simple and powerful; and (6) they should have an element of surprise. How well does the theory of evolution by natural selection fulfill these six criteria?

678
views
Textbook Question

What is an evolutionary adaptation?

a. A trait that improves the fitness of its bearer, compared with individuals without the trait

b. A trait that changes in response to environmental influences within the individual's lifetime

c. The ability of an individual to adjust to its environment

d. A trait that an individual wants so that it can survive

1179
views
Textbook Question

Most mice living on the mainland of Florida are brown, but the mice that live on the sand dunes of the barrier islands have white fur. The differences in color are heritable, determined by genes such as MC1R. It is intuitive that the light color of beach-dwelling mice is an adaptation for blending into their environment—and thus evading predators. Apply Darwin's four postulates to a population of mice living on sand dunes in coastal Florida.

1086
views
Textbook Question
A team led by evolutionary biologist Hopi Hoekstra set out to test the hypothesis that predators are an agent of natural selection on mouse color. They made 250 plasticine models of mice that were alike in every way except that half were painted white and half were painted brown. Suggest one advantage and one disadvantage of using model mice instead of real mice in this experiment.
1100
views