Skip to main content
Pearson+ LogoPearson+ Logo
Ch.11 Nuclear Chemistry
McMurry - Fundamentals of GOB 8th Edition
McMurry8th EditionFundamentals of GOBISBN: 9780134015187Not the one you use?Change textbook
Chapter 11, Problem 73

Why is a scintillation counter or Geiger counter more useful for determining the existence and source of a new radiation leak than a film badge?

Verified step by step guidance
1
Understand the purpose of each device: A scintillation counter and a Geiger counter are active radiation detection devices that provide real-time measurements of radiation levels, while a film badge is a passive device that records cumulative radiation exposure over time.
Recognize the need for real-time detection: In the case of a new radiation leak, it is crucial to detect radiation immediately to identify its presence and source. Active devices like scintillation counters and Geiger counters are designed for this purpose.
Explain the limitations of a film badge: A film badge does not provide immediate feedback. It requires processing and analysis after exposure, making it unsuitable for detecting a new radiation leak in real-time.
Highlight the sensitivity of active detectors: Scintillation counters and Geiger counters are highly sensitive to radiation and can detect even small changes in radiation levels, which is essential for pinpointing the source of a leak.
Conclude with the practicality of active devices: The portability, real-time feedback, and sensitivity of scintillation counters and Geiger counters make them more effective tools for identifying and addressing new radiation leaks compared to film badges.

Verified video answer for a similar problem:

This video solution was recommended by our tutors as helpful for the problem above.
Video duration:
1m
Was this helpful?

Key Concepts

Here are the essential concepts you must grasp in order to answer the question correctly.

Scintillation Counter

A scintillation counter is a device that detects and measures ionizing radiation by using a scintillator material that emits light when radiation interacts with it. This light is then converted into an electrical signal, allowing for real-time monitoring and quantification of radiation levels. Its sensitivity and ability to identify different types of radiation make it particularly useful for detecting radiation leaks.
Recommended video:
Guided course
01:23
Electronic Structure: Electron Spin Concept 1

Geiger Counter

A Geiger counter is an instrument that measures ionizing radiation through the ionization of gas within a Geiger-Müller tube. It provides immediate feedback on radiation levels and can detect alpha, beta, and gamma radiation. Its portability and ease of use make it an effective tool for quickly assessing radiation hazards in the environment, especially in emergency situations.
Recommended video:
Guided course
04:22
Rutherford Gold Foil Oil Experiment

Film Badge

A film badge is a personal dosimeter that uses photographic film to measure accumulated radiation exposure over time. While it is useful for monitoring long-term exposure in workers, it lacks the immediate feedback and sensitivity of electronic detectors like scintillation counters and Geiger counters. Consequently, film badges are less effective for quickly identifying and assessing radiation leaks.