教室を超えた成功の構築:批判的思考と評価

Christina Cavage
子供たちのグループは、先生と一緒にテーブルに立って、彼女が紙に何かを書き留めるのを見ていました
所要時間: 4分間

批判的思考と評価に関連する一般的な神話がいくつかあります。多くの人は、特に言語が限られているクラスでは、批判的思考を評価することは不可能だと考えています。しかし、それは可能です!ここで成功の鍵となるのは、言語スキルと認知スキルを分離できるタスクとルーブリックを作成することです。結局のところ、言語レベルが低いからといって、必ずしも生徒の批判的思考能力を反映しているわけではありません。

では、生徒が何を知っているかだけでなく、 どのように知っているか を測定するにはどうすればよいでしょうか。

批判的思考を測定する方法

まず、公式評価と非公式評価の2種類の評価を検討する必要があります。正式な評価は、タスク、レッスン、またはスキル構築活動の終了時に行われる傾向があり、通常は生徒が作成した作業に焦点を当てます。その後、非公式の評価を行います。これらは、その場でのやり取りを含む評価です。これらのタイプの評価は、批判的思考を測定する上で重要な役割を果たします。

批判的思考を教え、評価するためのヒント
再生
プライバシーとクッキー

視聴することにより、Pearsonがあなたの視聴データを1年間の間、マーケティングおよび分析のために共有することに同意したものとみなされます。クッキーを削除することで、同意を取り消すことができます。

正式な評価

評価は、生徒が生み出す最終的な作品にのみ焦点を当てるべきであるという誤解がよくあります。最終的な「製品」は紛れもなく重要であり、多くの場合、言語能力の理想的な尺度です。しかし、最終的な作品を作成するプロセスでは、生徒の批判的思考スキルが実際に発揮されているのを見ることができます。

言語的思考と批判的思考の両方を測定するルーブリックを設計する際には、言語的思考と批判的思考のどちらか一方だけに焦点を絞るようにしましょう。これらの異なるスキルを念頭に置くことで、言語スキルと批判的思考スキルを区別し、正式な評価に関してはそれらを別々に評価することができます。

言語スキルを測定するときは、ブルームの初期または基本的な認知領域をモデルとして使用します。

これらの項目を測定すると、実際には言語スキルを測定していることになります。たとえば、読書活動では、次のような質問をすることがあります。

  • 誰についての話ですか?
  • 物語の舞台はどこで?
  • ストーリーの主なアイデアは何ですか?

彼らは全体的な組織と主要な語彙を理解できますか?これらのタイプの質問は、学生の言語能力を評価します。

そして、批判的思考に関しては、ブルームの認知領域のより高度なレベルが有用なガイドを提供します。

これらのタイプの質問は、学生のメタ認知または批判的思考を評価します。

  • ストーリーにとって最も重要なキャラクターは誰ですか?
  • なぜでしょうか。
  • キャラクターの行動に同意しますか、それとも同意しませんか?
  • なぜですか、なぜそうでないのですか?

評価における言語と批判的思考の明確な分離は、各学生の両方のスキルの進歩を測定するのに役立ちます。

非公式の評価

これらの非公式の評価はどうですか?その場での評価では、批判的思考と言語スキルを明確に描写するのが難しい場合があります。

たとえば、グループワークを割り当てている場合は、学生同士のやり取りのチェックリストを保管することを検討してください。チェックリストの項目には、次のようなものがあります。

  • 誰が推論したのか?
  • 他の学生のアイデアの理由を提供したのは誰ですか?
  • 誰が比較したのか?
  • 誰が結論を出したのか?

また、生徒にチェックリストを保管してもらい、これらの質問を電子掲示板に投稿するように依頼することもできます。自己評価と同様に、これらのピアツーピア評価は、生徒に反省と気づきを促すことができます。

ルーブリックは、非公式の評価にも役立ちます。例えば、学生にエッセイの準備や執筆を依頼したとします。批判的思考を測定するために、各学生がエッセイに取り組んでいるときのアイデア出しプロセスを見ることができます。

  • 学生は考えられるすべてのトピックを見ていますか?
  • 学生が選択したオプションを選択する要因は何ですか?
  • 彼らは他のアイデアを認識していますか?

これらの質問に対する答えは、生徒が批判的に考えているかどうかを教えてくれます。

他のスキルと同様に、批判的思考の評価は公式にも非公式にも行う必要があります。プロセスと最終製品の両方を考慮する必要があります。そして、その際、言語スキルとメタ認知を区別するルーブリックを慎重に設計する必要があります。

Pearson からの他のブログ

  • Students sat outside sat on grass, with a teacher in the middle on a laptop
    Green education: Integrating sustainability into English lessons
    投稿者 Charlotte Guest
    所要時間: 5 minutes

    If you teach English, you already know the subject is secretly a life skills course in disguise. You don’t just teach grammar and essays; you teach students how to notice, question, empathize, argue, imagine and make meaning. That’s exactly why English is one of the most natural places to weave in sustainability.

    Green education doesn’t have to mean swapping your entire curriculum for climate documentaries or forcing every creative writing prompt to involve melting ice caps. It can be quieter (and often more powerful): selecting texts with environmental angles, inviting students to think critically about the language used in climate communication, and encouraging them to write for real audiences and with real-world stakes.

    Below are ways to integrate sustainability into English lessons while still meeting literacy goals, plus a note on using AI consciously – because even our digital tools come with an environmental footprint.

    1. Start with “green reading”: texts that open doors, not close them

    The simplest entry point is text selection. Sustainability themes appear across genres and time periods, and you can choose materials that fit your students’ maturity level and your existing curriculum goals.

    Ideas to try:

    • Short stories that explore human-nature relationships, scarcity, or future societies shaped by environmental change.
    • Poetry that foregrounds place, seasons, biodiversity or loss. Nature poetry is an easy bridge into imagery, tone and figurative language.
    • Nonfiction articles on fast fashion, food waste, wildfires, local conservation projects or “greenwashing” in advertising.
    • Speeches and opinion pieces that let students analyze rhetoric, claims, evidence, emotional appeals and bias.

    A useful approach is to build a “paired text” routine: pair a literary text with a current nonfiction piece. Students can practice comparative analysis while also seeing how themes evolve from art into public discourse.

    2. Teach language as power: sustainability is a rhetoric unit waiting to happen

    Sustainability conversations are full of persuasive language, sometimes honest, sometimes manipulative. That makes them perfect material for rhetoric and media literacy.

    Mini-lessons you can try:

    • Greenwashing detective work: bring in ads or brand sustainability statements. Ask: What claims are being made? What evidence is offered? What’s vague? What’s measurable?
    • Framing and connotation: compare “climate change” vs. “climate crisis,” “carbon-neutral” vs. “net zero,” “natural” vs. “organic.” What do these terms imply and who benefits?
    • Tone analysis: how do different outlets report the same environmental story? Neutral? Alarmist? Dismissive? Hopeful? Students can annotate for diction and bias.

    This helps students become more thoughtful readers and more ethical communicators, two outcomes worth aiming for even when the topic isn’t sustainability.

    3. Make writing real: sustainability projects with authentic audiences

    When students feel their writing has a purpose beyond “hand it in, get a grade”, quality and investment usually rise. Sustainability offers plenty of authentic writing opportunities, even at a small scale.

    Writing tasks that work well:

    • Letters or emails to the school administration proposing a realistic change (recycling signage, reducing single-use plastics at events, a second-hand uniform swap).
    • Op-eds for the school newsletter on an issue students care about (food waste in the cafeteria, bus vs. car drop-offs, energy use).
    • Instructional writing: “How to…” guides for greener habits (thrifting, repairing clothes, reducing digital clutter).
    • Podcast scripts or short documentary-style narration about a local environmental story.

    The trick is to keep the scope manageable. Sustainability writing doesn’t need to save the planet; it needs to strengthen students’ ability to argue clearly, use credible evidence and write with voice.

    4. Use storytelling to build empathy and avoid burnout

    Many students feel overwhelmed by environmental news. English teachers are well placed to counter “doom fatigue” by using narrative, especially stories that hold complexity.

    Try prompts that balance realism with agency:

    • Write a scene where a character makes a small decision that has ripple effects.
    • Create a “future news report” set 20 years from now, showing both challenges and adaptations.
    • Write from a non-human perspective (a river, an old tree, an urban fox) to practice voice and point of view.

    The goal isn’t to sugarcoat realities, but to make room for imagination and nuance: people can be contradictory; systems shape choices; hope can be practical, not sentimental.

    5. Build sustainability into routine classroom habits (so it’s not just a topic)

    Sometimes, green education is less about what you teach and more about how the classroom runs.

    Small changes can become teachable moments:

    • Encourage digital submissions only when they truly help, and be mindful of unnecessary printing (but also avoid assuming digital is “free”; more on that below).
    • Reuse materials. Create a “paper bank” for scrap writing and drafting.
    • Do a short “language + environment” warm-up once a week: a new word (like “circular economy” or “biodiversity”) used in a sentence, then discussed for nuance.

    When sustainability becomes the norm rather than a special unit, students absorb it as part of everyday thinking.

    6. A necessary addition: conscious use of AI (because it has an environmental cost)

    AI can be a helpful classroom tool, especially for brainstorming, drafting models, generating sentence stems or supporting students who struggle to start. But it’s worth naming what often stays invisible: AI requires energy. Data centers, model training and even repeated daily queries contribute to electricity and water use, depending on how systems are cooled and powered.

    That doesn’t mean “never use AI”. It means modelling the same critical thinking we want students to use everywhere else: use it with intention.

    Practical guidelines for greener, more ethical AI use:

    • Use AI when it replaces a bigger footprint. For example, generating one strong mentor text instead of printing five random worksheets.
    • Batch tasks. One well-planned prompt is better than ten quick “try again” prompts.
    • Teach prompt discipline. Have students plan what they want first, then query once. This improves learning and reduces unnecessary use.
    • Be transparent. Treat AI like a tool with trade-offs: useful, imperfect and not environmentally neutral.
    • Prioritize human thinking. AI should support reading and writing, not replace the process that actually builds skill.

    Framing AI this way turns it into another sustainability lesson: every choice. digital or physical, has a cost, and responsible people learn to weigh trade-offs.

    English is where sustainability becomes personal

    Sustainability isn’t only a science topic; it’s a human story. It’s about values, choices, culture, language, power and the way we imagine the future. English teachers already teach students how to read between lines and write with purpose. Integrating eco-conscious tasks simply gives those skills somewhere urgent and real to land.

    Start small: a poem, a paired article, a writing task with an authentic audience, a quick discussion about greenwashing, a mindful approach to AI. Over time, your classroom can become a place where students don’t just learn English, they learn how to speak for the world they’re growing up in.

  • A man with headphones on listening and smiling while he sits on a sofa
    11 great English-language song lyrics
    投稿者 Steffanie Zazulak
    所要時間: 5 minutes

    What is it about music that helps boost your English skills, confidence and pronunciation? A song can provide an emotional connection between the music and the listener, providing learners with new ways to express their feelings. Music and rhythm have also been shown to benefit memorization, which is a key component of learning.
    Here are some of our favorite lyrics to some of our favorite songs:

    1. The Beatles – Blackbird

    The Beatles are the best band to help you learn English. There are many Beatles songs with catchy melodies and simple lyrics, but Blackbird captures the Fab Four at their most poetic:
    Blackbird singing in the dead of night
    Take these broken wings and learn to fly
    All your life
    You were only waiting for this moment to arise

    2. The Cure – Friday I’m In Love

    This song is a great way to help learn the days of the week (that may be obvious). Love is also a very popular English word, so this one is for all the romantics out there.

    Always take a big bite
    It’s such a gorgeous sight
    To see you eat in the middle of the night

    3. Ed Sheeran – Thinking Out Loud

    Another one for the lovers: Ed’s heartfelt lyrics usually do well on the mainstream pop charts; he's one of the world's most popular songwriters. In this ballad, he tells the sweet story of long-time love.

    Take me into your loving arms
    Kiss me under the light of a thousand stars
    Place your head on my beating heart

  • Children and teacher looking at a tablet smiling and laughing in the classroom
    Incorporating reflection activities to kickstart the New Year
    投稿者 Charlotte Guest
    所要時間: 5 minutes

    A new calendar year offers a natural reset, an opportunity for your learners to pause, look back and lean forward with purpose. Reflection isn’t just a feel-good exercise; it’s a powerful learning accelerator. It helps students consolidate knowledge, develop metacognition and set actionable goals. It also helps you, the teacher, gain insights into what’s working, what needs adjustment and how to sustain momentum. Below are activities that fit into real classrooms and real schedules, with variations for different age groups and subject areas.

    Why start with reflection?

    Reflection builds self-awareness and agency. When students name what they’ve learned and where they want to grow, they’re more likely to persevere and achieve. For you, structured reflection provides a clearer picture of learning gaps and strengths, enabling intentional planning. Think of these routines as small investments that pay off in greater engagement, clearer goals and smoother instruction all year long.

    Quick wins you can do in one class period

    Rose–Thorn–Bud

    • Purpose: Recognize successes ("rose"), challenges ("thorn") and emerging opportunities ("bud").
    • How-to: Give students three sticky notes or three boxes on a digital form. Prompt: “One thing that went well last term”, “One challenge I faced”, “One idea I want to try”.
    • Teacher moves: Sort responses to identify class-wide trends. Celebrate roses. Normalize thorns with a growth mindset. Turn buds into a short list of new strategies to try together.
    • Variations: Pair-share for younger grades; content-specific (rose = strategy that helped with fractions, thorn = multi-step problems, bud = practice with word problems).

    Start–Stop–Continue

    • Purpose: Turn reflection into immediate behavior and study habits.
    • How-to: Ask students to list one habit to start, one to stop, and one to continue this term. Provide sentence stems: “I will start…”, “I will stop…”, “I will continue… because…”
    • Teacher moves: Have students star the one they’ll commit to this week and set a check-in date. Invite a brief self-assessment after two weeks.
    • Variations: Subject-specific (start annotating texts, stop cramming, continue reviewing notes nightly).

    3–2–1 Learning snapshot

    • Purpose: Capture key learning quickly.
    • How-to: Prompt with “three concepts I understand now”, “two questions I still have” and “one resource or strategy that helped me learn”.
    • Teacher moves: Use the “two questions” to plan mini-lessons or office-hours topics. Share a class list of “one resource” to build a peer-sourced toolkit.
    • Tools: Paper exit tickets or a quick digital form, whatever is easier and quicker for you. 

    Peer reflection interviews

    • Purpose: Build belonging and metacognition through conversation.
    • How-to: In pairs, students ask: “What’s one thing you’re proud of from last term?”, “When did you feel stuck – and how did you get unstuck?”, “What’s a goal you have for this month?”
    • Teacher moves: Teach active listening (eye contact, paraphrasing) and capture themes. Close with a 2-minute write: “One insight I gained from my partner.”
    • Variations: Record short audio or video reflections for classes using multimedia tools.

    Two stars and a wish (Portfolio refresh)

    • Purpose: Reflect using evidence.
    • How-to: Students choose two artifacts from last term to highlight ("stars") and one area to improve ("wish"). They attach a brief reflection: what it shows and why it matters.
    • Teacher moves: Model with your own sample. Provide a rubric for reflective depth (specificity, evidence, next steps).
    • Variations: Early grades can draw or use photos; older students link to digital artifacts.

    Deeper dives for week-one routines

    Personal learning timeline

    • Purpose: See growth over time and connect effort to outcomes.
    • How-to: Students draw a timeline of the term: key topics, pivotal moments, breakthroughs, setbacks and supports that helped. They mark future milestones: “By Week 4, I will…”
    • Teacher moves: Guide students to identify strategies that worked (study groups, retrieval practice), then add them to their plan. Create wall or digital gallery for optional sharing.
    • Extension: Have students revisit the timeline mid-term to add new milestones.

    Goal-setting conferences

    • Purpose: Craft specific, measurable goals with support.
    • How-to: Provide a short goal sheet: “My priority skill”, “Evidence I’ll use”, “Daily/weekly actions”, “Support I need”, “Check-in date”.
    • Teacher moves: Rotate through 3-minute conferences to coach students toward clarity and feasibility. Encourage process goals (such as practicing 10 minutes daily) alongside performance goals.
    • Variations: Small-group coaching if individual conferences aren’t feasible; student-led with peer feedback for time efficiency.

    Class norms refresh (Community agreements)

    • Purpose: Re-center your classroom culture.
    • How-to: Invite students to propose two norms that helped learning and one to adjust. Synthesize into 5–7 concise agreements.
    • Teacher moves: Co-create routines that enact the norms (silent start, exit reflections, peer tutoring). Post and practice with brief weekly check-ins.
    • Equity lens: Ensure norms protect voice and belonging, not just compliance.

    Make it stick: Implementation tips

    • Keep it short and regular. Even just 5–10 minutes a week builds powerful habits.
    • Use sentence stems to reduce cognitive load: “A strategy that helped me was…”, “Next time I’ll try…”
    • Celebrate progress. Highlight student reflections that show growth, not just perfection.
    • Close the loop. Bring reflections back into instruction: “I noticed many of you asked about synthesizing sources—let’s start with a mini-lesson.”
    • Make it visible. A reflection wall or digital board keeps goals at the forefront.

    Inclusive informed considerations

    • Offer multiple modalities: writing, drawing, audio or a private form. Choice increases safety and authenticity.
    • Normalize struggle and curiosity. Use language that validates effort: “Challenges are data, not defects”.
    • Protect privacy. Invite, but don’t require, public sharing. Summarize themes anonymously.

    Using tools you already have

    Many of you use courseware, dashboards and assessment reports. Use them to ground reflection in evidence:

    • Pull a quick progress report to anchor 3–2–1 reflections in actual performance trends.
    • Use item analysis to identify common thorns and plan targeted practice.
    • Invite students to look at their data with you during goal-setting conferences.

    A quick start plan for week one

    • Day 1: Rose–Thorn–Bud plus a short norms refresh.
    • Day 2: 3–2–1 Learning Snapshot tied to last term’s key skills.
    • Day 3–4: Goal-setting conferences; peers do Two Stars and a Wish.
    • Day 5: Personal Learning Timeline and a brief share-out; set check-in dates.

    Reflection is a powerful tool. Begin small, stay consistent and let students’ feedback guide you. With clear prompts, support and the right tools, including Pearson’s, you can turn New Year’s energy into steady progress for your class.