教室を超えた成功の構築:批判的思考と評価

Christina Cavage
子供たちのグループは、先生と一緒にテーブルに立って、彼女が紙に何かを書き留めるのを見ていました
所要時間: 4分間

批判的思考と評価に関連する一般的な神話がいくつかあります。多くの人は、特に言語が限られているクラスでは、批判的思考を評価することは不可能だと考えています。しかし、それは可能です!ここで成功の鍵となるのは、言語スキルと認知スキルを分離できるタスクとルーブリックを作成することです。結局のところ、言語レベルが低いからといって、必ずしも生徒の批判的思考能力を反映しているわけではありません。

では、生徒が何を知っているかだけでなく、 どのように知っているか を測定するにはどうすればよいでしょうか。

批判的思考を測定する方法

まず、公式評価と非公式評価の2種類の評価を検討する必要があります。正式な評価は、タスク、レッスン、またはスキル構築活動の終了時に行われる傾向があり、通常は生徒が作成した作業に焦点を当てます。その後、非公式の評価を行います。これらは、その場でのやり取りを含む評価です。これらのタイプの評価は、批判的思考を測定する上で重要な役割を果たします。

批判的思考を教え、評価するためのヒント
再生
プライバシーとクッキー

視聴することにより、Pearsonがあなたの視聴データを1年間の間、マーケティングおよび分析のために共有することに同意したものとみなされます。クッキーを削除することで、同意を取り消すことができます。

正式な評価

評価は、生徒が生み出す最終的な作品にのみ焦点を当てるべきであるという誤解がよくあります。最終的な「製品」は紛れもなく重要であり、多くの場合、言語能力の理想的な尺度です。しかし、最終的な作品を作成するプロセスでは、生徒の批判的思考スキルが実際に発揮されているのを見ることができます。

言語的思考と批判的思考の両方を測定するルーブリックを設計する際には、言語的思考と批判的思考のどちらか一方だけに焦点を絞るようにしましょう。これらの異なるスキルを念頭に置くことで、言語スキルと批判的思考スキルを区別し、正式な評価に関してはそれらを別々に評価することができます。

言語スキルを測定するときは、ブルームの初期または基本的な認知領域をモデルとして使用します。

これらの項目を測定すると、実際には言語スキルを測定していることになります。たとえば、読書活動では、次のような質問をすることがあります。

  • 誰についての話ですか?
  • 物語の舞台はどこで?
  • ストーリーの主なアイデアは何ですか?

彼らは全体的な組織と主要な語彙を理解できますか?これらのタイプの質問は、学生の言語能力を評価します。

そして、批判的思考に関しては、ブルームの認知領域のより高度なレベルが有用なガイドを提供します。

これらのタイプの質問は、学生のメタ認知または批判的思考を評価します。

  • ストーリーにとって最も重要なキャラクターは誰ですか?
  • なぜでしょうか。
  • キャラクターの行動に同意しますか、それとも同意しませんか?
  • なぜですか、なぜそうでないのですか?

評価における言語と批判的思考の明確な分離は、各学生の両方のスキルの進歩を測定するのに役立ちます。

非公式の評価

これらの非公式の評価はどうですか?その場での評価では、批判的思考と言語スキルを明確に描写するのが難しい場合があります。

たとえば、グループワークを割り当てている場合は、学生同士のやり取りのチェックリストを保管することを検討してください。チェックリストの項目には、次のようなものがあります。

  • 誰が推論したのか?
  • 他の学生のアイデアの理由を提供したのは誰ですか?
  • 誰が比較したのか?
  • 誰が結論を出したのか?

また、生徒にチェックリストを保管してもらい、これらの質問を電子掲示板に投稿するように依頼することもできます。自己評価と同様に、これらのピアツーピア評価は、生徒に反省と気づきを促すことができます。

ルーブリックは、非公式の評価にも役立ちます。例えば、学生にエッセイの準備や執筆を依頼したとします。批判的思考を測定するために、各学生がエッセイに取り組んでいるときのアイデア出しプロセスを見ることができます。

  • 学生は考えられるすべてのトピックを見ていますか?
  • 学生が選択したオプションを選択する要因は何ですか?
  • 彼らは他のアイデアを認識していますか?

これらの質問に対する答えは、生徒が批判的に考えているかどうかを教えてくれます。

他のスキルと同様に、批判的思考の評価は公式にも非公式にも行う必要があります。プロセスと最終製品の両方を考慮する必要があります。そして、その際、言語スキルとメタ認知を区別するルーブリックを慎重に設計する必要があります。

Pearson からの他のブログ

  • A man sat in a pod chair working on laptop
    A teacher's guide to safe and ethical AI use for students
    投稿者 Charlotte Guest
    所要時間: 5 minutes

    Artificial Intelligence (AI) is becoming a normal part of education. Many students now use AI tools like ChatGPT, Gemini and Microsoft Copilot to help with homework, writing, studying and even learning new languages.

    These tools can be very helpful, but they also bring new challenges. Some students use AI to improve their understanding, while others may rely on it too much or copy its answers without thinking.

    Teachers have an important role to play. Instead of telling their students not to use AI, they can teach them to use it use it safely, responsibly and ethically. When students understand both the benefits and the risks, they can use AI to become better learners rather than simply finding shortcuts.

    What does ethical AI use mean?

    Ethical AI use means using AI in a fair, honest and responsible way.

    Students should think of AI as a learning assistant, not as someone who completes their work for them. AI can explain grammar, suggest vocabulary, give writing feedback or help students practise conversations. However, students should still make their own decisions, solve problems and create their own work.

    A simple rule to remember is:

    Use AI to support your learning, not replace it.

    This mindset helps students develop real language skills and become more confident learners.

    Talk openly about AI in the classroom

    Many students are already using AI, whether teachers ask them to or not. Because of this, it's important to create an open and honest conversation about AI rather than ignoring it.

    When students know they can ask questions without being judged, they are more likely to use AI responsibly. Explain when AI is helpful, when it should not be used and why learning still requires effort and practice.

    Every school may have different rules about AI, so make sure your students understand your expectations. If everyone knows what is allowed and what is not, there is much less confusion.

    Show students how AI can support learning

    AI works best when it helps students think, practice and improve.

    For example, students can ask AI to:

    • Explain difficult grammar rules
    • Create vocabulary quizzes
    • Suggest speaking questions
    • Practice everyday conversations
    • Check writing for grammar and spelling mistakes
    • Rewrite a text using simpler or more advanced English
    • Generate ideas before starting a writing task

    These activities encourage active learning because students are still involved in the process.

    However, AI should not be used to write essays, complete homework or answer exam questions without the student's own effort. If AI does everything, the student misses valuable opportunities to practice and improve.

    Protect students' privacy

    One of the most important lessons teachers can share is how to protect personal information online.

    Students should understand that AI tools may store conversations or use them to improve their systems. Because of this, they should never share private or sensitive information.

    Remind students not to enter:

    • Full names
    • Home addresses
    • Phone numbers
    • Passwords
    • Personal photos
    • School records
    • Private information about friends or family

    Instead, encourage students to use general examples when asking questions.

    For example, instead of sharing a real student's name in a piece of writing, they can simply say "the student" or create a fictional example.

    Learning to protect personal information is an important digital skill that goes beyond using AI.

    Teach students to question AI's answers

    AI is impressive, but it is not perfect.

    Sometimes AI gives incorrect information, misunderstands a question or even invents facts and references. Because AI often sounds confident, students may believe everything it says without checking.

    This is why critical thinking remains essential.

    Encourage students to ask themselves questions such as:

    • Does this answer make sense?
    • Can I find the same information somewhere else?
    • Would my teacher agree with this explanation?
    • Have I understood the answer or am I just copying it?

    Helping students develop these habits will make them stronger learners long after they leave the classroom.

    Encourage honesty and responsibility

    Being honest about AI use is an important part of academic integrity.

    If students use AI to brainstorm ideas, improve grammar or practice vocabulary, that can be a positive learning experience. However, they should not pretend that AI-generated work is completely their own if school policies require them to explain how AI was used.

    Teachers can make this easier by clearly explaining what is acceptable in different activities. For example, AI might be allowed for homework planning but not during assessments or exams.

    When expectations are clear, students are more likely to make responsible choices.

    Create simple classroom AI guidelines

    Instead of giving students a long list of rules, try creating a short classroom agreement together.

    You could ask students questions like:

    • When is AI useful?
    • When should we avoid using AI?
    • What does responsible AI use look like?
    • How can AI help us become better language learners?

    Together, you can create a simple agreement such as:

    • I will use AI to help me learn.
    • I will think before accepting AI's answers.
    • I will check important information.
    • I will not copy AI work and claim it as my own.
    • I will protect my personal information.
    • I will ask my teacher if I am unsure.

    When students help create the rules, they often feel more responsible for following them.

    Remember that teachers are still essential

    Some people worry that AI will replace teachers. In reality, AI cannot replace the human side of teaching.

    Teachers motivate students, answer unexpected questions, understand emotions and adapt lessons to meet individual needs. They encourage creativity, build confidence and create meaningful relationships in the classroom.

    AI can provide information, but it cannot replace encouragement, empathy or the experience that teachers bring every day.

    The best classrooms will combine the strengths of both teachers and technology.

    Supporting safe AI use in language learning

    AI is likely to remain an important part of education and language learners can benefit greatly from using it effectively. Instead of seeing AI as something to fear, teachers can help students understand how to use it safely, ethically and responsibly.

    By encouraging critical thinking, protecting privacy, promoting honesty and showing students how AI can support learning rather than replace it, we prepare them for a future where technology plays an important role.

    The goal isn't to stop students from using AI. The goal is to help them become confident, independent learners who know how to use these powerful tools wisely. With clear guidance from teachers, AI can become a valuable learning partner as students continue to develop the language skills and critical-thinking abilities they need for success.

  • Young woman writing in a notepad whilst looking at a laptop and wearing headphones
    Top tips for last-minute language exam prep
    投稿者 Charlotte Guest
    所要時間: 4 minutes

    Is your language exam only a few days away? Don't worry. Many students feel nervous before an exam, especially if they think they have not studied enough. The good news is that you can still use your time well. A few smart study habits can help you feel more confident and ready.

    Here are some simple and practical tips to help you prepare for your language exam at the last minute.

    1. Focus on the most important topics

    Don't try to learn everything. Instead, think about the topics that often appear in your lessons or practice tests. Spend more time on grammar points, vocabulary and skills that are likely to be in the exam.

    For example, if your course often tests the past tense, question words or common travel vocabulary, review those first instead of learning new topics.

    If you have old class notes or practice papers, use them. They can show you what you should review first.

    2. Review vocabulary every day

    Learning a few new words is good, but reviewing words you already know is even better before an exam.

    Write down important words and phrases. Read them aloud and try to use them in simple sentences. For example, if you are reviewing the word "appointment", you could write:

    • I have a doctor's appointment tomorrow.
    • She arrived early for her appointment.

    You can also use flashcards or a vocabulary app to test yourself. Short review sessions of 10 to 15 minutes can be very effective.

  • A woman on a laptop with headphones on and writing down on paper
    Are online checks reliable for English tests?
    投稿者 Alice Bazzi
    所要時間: 3 minutes

    Identity verification is one of the most critical steps in any English language test. For institutions and governments, the question is clear: can online ID checks really be trusted? With modern technology, the answer is simply yes. And, in many cases, they are even more robust than manual checks. 

    PTE Express uses advanced biometric verification, combining facial recognition with real-time ID validation. Candidates are required to present official identification, which is cross-checked using automated systems that detect inconsistencies, fraudulent markers and different forms of tampering. 

    What makes this approach particularly powerful is the consistency. Unlike human-led checks, which can vary depending on conditions, staff training or volume, AI-driven verification applies the same rigorous standard to every candidate. 

    Additionally, liveness detection technology ensures that the person taking the tests are physically present and not using any static image or recording. This eliminates common fraud risks that are associated with impersonation.