教室を超えた成功の構築:批判的思考と評価

Christina Cavage
子供たちのグループは、先生と一緒にテーブルに立って、彼女が紙に何かを書き留めるのを見ていました
所要時間: 4分間

批判的思考と評価に関連する一般的な神話がいくつかあります。多くの人は、特に言語が限られているクラスでは、批判的思考を評価することは不可能だと考えています。しかし、それは可能です!ここで成功の鍵となるのは、言語スキルと認知スキルを分離できるタスクとルーブリックを作成することです。結局のところ、言語レベルが低いからといって、必ずしも生徒の批判的思考能力を反映しているわけではありません。

では、生徒が何を知っているかだけでなく、 どのように知っているか を測定するにはどうすればよいでしょうか。

批判的思考を測定する方法

まず、公式評価と非公式評価の2種類の評価を検討する必要があります。正式な評価は、タスク、レッスン、またはスキル構築活動の終了時に行われる傾向があり、通常は生徒が作成した作業に焦点を当てます。その後、非公式の評価を行います。これらは、その場でのやり取りを含む評価です。これらのタイプの評価は、批判的思考を測定する上で重要な役割を果たします。

批判的思考を教え、評価するためのヒント
再生
プライバシーとクッキー

視聴することにより、Pearsonがあなたの視聴データを1年間の間、マーケティングおよび分析のために共有することに同意したものとみなされます。クッキーを削除することで、同意を取り消すことができます。

正式な評価

評価は、生徒が生み出す最終的な作品にのみ焦点を当てるべきであるという誤解がよくあります。最終的な「製品」は紛れもなく重要であり、多くの場合、言語能力の理想的な尺度です。しかし、最終的な作品を作成するプロセスでは、生徒の批判的思考スキルが実際に発揮されているのを見ることができます。

言語的思考と批判的思考の両方を測定するルーブリックを設計する際には、言語的思考と批判的思考のどちらか一方だけに焦点を絞るようにしましょう。これらの異なるスキルを念頭に置くことで、言語スキルと批判的思考スキルを区別し、正式な評価に関してはそれらを別々に評価することができます。

言語スキルを測定するときは、ブルームの初期または基本的な認知領域をモデルとして使用します。

これらの項目を測定すると、実際には言語スキルを測定していることになります。たとえば、読書活動では、次のような質問をすることがあります。

  • 誰についての話ですか?
  • 物語の舞台はどこで?
  • ストーリーの主なアイデアは何ですか?

彼らは全体的な組織と主要な語彙を理解できますか?これらのタイプの質問は、学生の言語能力を評価します。

そして、批判的思考に関しては、ブルームの認知領域のより高度なレベルが有用なガイドを提供します。

これらのタイプの質問は、学生のメタ認知または批判的思考を評価します。

  • ストーリーにとって最も重要なキャラクターは誰ですか?
  • なぜでしょうか。
  • キャラクターの行動に同意しますか、それとも同意しませんか?
  • なぜですか、なぜそうでないのですか?

評価における言語と批判的思考の明確な分離は、各学生の両方のスキルの進歩を測定するのに役立ちます。

非公式の評価

これらの非公式の評価はどうですか?その場での評価では、批判的思考と言語スキルを明確に描写するのが難しい場合があります。

たとえば、グループワークを割り当てている場合は、学生同士のやり取りのチェックリストを保管することを検討してください。チェックリストの項目には、次のようなものがあります。

  • 誰が推論したのか?
  • 他の学生のアイデアの理由を提供したのは誰ですか?
  • 誰が比較したのか?
  • 誰が結論を出したのか?

また、生徒にチェックリストを保管してもらい、これらの質問を電子掲示板に投稿するように依頼することもできます。自己評価と同様に、これらのピアツーピア評価は、生徒に反省と気づきを促すことができます。

ルーブリックは、非公式の評価にも役立ちます。例えば、学生にエッセイの準備や執筆を依頼したとします。批判的思考を測定するために、各学生がエッセイに取り組んでいるときのアイデア出しプロセスを見ることができます。

  • 学生は考えられるすべてのトピックを見ていますか?
  • 学生が選択したオプションを選択する要因は何ですか?
  • 彼らは他のアイデアを認識していますか?

これらの質問に対する答えは、生徒が批判的に考えているかどうかを教えてくれます。

他のスキルと同様に、批判的思考の評価は公式にも非公式にも行う必要があります。プロセスと最終製品の両方を考慮する必要があります。そして、その際、言語スキルとメタ認知を区別するルーブリックを慎重に設計する必要があります。

Pearson からの他のブログ

  • A group of students sat together smiling outside
    5 team building activities to help break down boundaries
    投稿者 Anna Roslaniec
    所要時間: 4 minutes

    At the beginning of term adolescent learners are often shy, embarrassed and awkward. They are reluctant to speak English in front of their peers or show enthusiasm in class, often suffering from social pressure and lack of self-confidence. It can take weeks or months for students to get to know each other and form bonds. However, don’t despair if your teen learners are like this. There are plenty of team-building games and activities you can do to help students build relationships that will allow them to feel comfortable and relaxed in the classroom.

    Team building activities to help break down boundaries

    Why use team-building activities in the classroom?

    Team building activities can help:

    • Break down boundaries
    • Teens get to know each other
    • Build trust and teamwork
    • Bring 21st-century skills - collaboration, communication, critical thinking, and problem-solving skills - to life

    Team-building games can also be a lot of fun. They require students to work together to reach a common goal and sometimes include a competitive element, which can encourage teenage learners to get really involved. There is a wealth of different team-building games and activities suitable for older children and teens, but here we have chosen five that we think your teenage learners will love.

    1) Human knot

    In this fun physical activity, teamwork is essential. Students form a human knot, which they have to work together to untangle. It will also give you an idea of which students show leadership qualities.

    Materials needed: none

    How to play:

    Have students stand in a circle, making sure they are close together. If you have a large class, having students play in two or more groups may be better. The larger the group, the more complicated the puzzle will be. Tell students to reach across the circle with each arm and hold the hands of two other students. They can't choose the people standing on either side of them. Make sure students hold a left hand with their left hand, and vice versa. Now the human knot is formed.

    Tell students that they have to try to untangle the knot without dropping the hands they are holding. When they have successfully untangled the knot, students will be standing in a regular circle holding hands. Students will need to bend, twist, and move under or step over other students' arms.

    Tip: If one student is reluctant to play, give them the role of "director". This student can walk around the outside of the knot, giving instructions to help the group solve the problem.

    If you are doing this in groups, have them race against each other. The team to solve the problem first - wins.

    2) Magic carpet

    In this game, teams stand on a "magic carpet" which they have to turn over while still standing on it. Teams must decide on a strategy together and carry it out — if they try to do it individually, someone will inevitably fall off.

    Materials needed: rugs, towels, or large pieces of cardboard (one per team)

    How to play:

    Give each team their magic carpet and have them stand on it. Tell students they are on a magic flying carpet high in the sky, but there's a problem — the carpet is upside down. They need to turn the carpet over without anyone falling off.

    They need to devise a strategy for turning the carpet over without anyone touching the floor. Teams can work individually, or they can collaborate to help each other.

    The activity can be set up as a race to see which team flips their carpet first.

    Tip: Encourage students to rethink their strategy if it doesn't appear to be working. Evaluating your decisions and adapting your plan is a useful 21st-century skill that students can use throughout the school year.

    3) Build it

    Teenage students love a practical challenge; in this activity, the element of competition will undoubtedly get them involved. With just basic materials, students have to work together to build the tallest freestanding tower within a time limit.

    Materials needed: balloons (one pack per team), sticky tape, a tape measure, balloon pumps (optional)

    How to play:

    Have students form teams of four and hand out the materials. Tell students to build the tallest freestanding tower using just balloons and sticky tape in ten minutes. Explain that after ten minutes, you will check and measure the structures. If it falls over, that team is eliminated from the challenge.

    Tell students how much time is left after five minutes and again two minutes before the time ends. Have teams stand back from their towers. Inspect each tower, measure it, and record the results. You may wish to give the winning team a prize.

    Tip: Increase the challenge by giving students mixed bags of different-shaped balloons, including modeling balloons.

    4) My eyes, your eyes

    Students will have lots of fun guiding each other or being guided through an obstacle course by their teammates. This activity tests communication skills and builds trust between pairs of students.

    Materials needed: blindfolds or scarves (one per pair) and obstacles, e.g., chairs and boxes.

    Preparation: Before the activity, set up the obstacle course by placing furniture and other items around the classroom. Decide where the route students take will begin and end, marking the finish line.

    How to play:

    Put students in pairs. If possible, have them work with a student they don't know very well. Have one student in each pair cover their eyes with a blindfold. This student is a blinded person and their partner will be their eyes. The guide stands behind their blind partner and places their hands on their partner's shoulders. Their job is to quietly give instructions to guide their partner towards the finish line, navigating the obstacles. The first pair to finish wins.

    Have students swap roles. Move some of the obstacles. Then repeat the activity.

    Tip: If possible, play the game in the playground or in the school gym. The larger the space, the more complex you can make the route.

    5) Scavenger hunt

    This is a longer activity that requires slightly more planning than the others. Teams will complete a set of tasks and challenges as a race. Choose a mixture of fun challenges and serious tasks to turn this activity into a fun diagnostic test to determine students' English levels.

    Materials needed: Worksheet containing a list of tasks and challenges (one per team). Tasks can be both language-related and practical.

    How to play:

    Put students into teams. This activity is ideal for students with different skills and abilities, so try to ensure teams are mixed-ability. Tell students that they are going to race to complete a series of tasks that they will find on their worksheet. The fastest team to complete all tasks correctly wins. Some tasks can be completed by one student.

    Explain that students don't need to complete the tasks in order. Point out that you will monitor them closely to ensure there is no cheating. Remind students that they must use English at all times. You can choose to penalize students by having them repeat or do an extra task if they use L1.

    Tip: If you think students might try to cheat, before you set the teams, nominate students to be team monitors (one per team). They will have the worksheet and make sure that the team fulfills each task. Alternatively, if students have mobile phones or tablets, have them take pictures and videos of their team members completing the task.

  • A woman stood at her computer smiling and raising a arm in celebration
    Do fast test results compromise accuracy and security?
    投稿者 Alice Bazzi
    所要時間: 2 minutes

    Speed is increasingly critical in global admissions. But with faster results comes an inevitable question: does speed compromise accuracy and security? 

    With traditional testing, long result timelines were often seen as a mark of thoroughness. Today, however, technology enables both speed and precision without any trade-offs. 

    PTE Express uses AI-powered scoring trained on large datasets of real tests responses, ensuring consistent and accurate evaluation across all candidates. Unlike manual grading, which can vary between examiners, automated scoring applies the same criteria to every response. In result, this reduces bias and increases reliability; two factors that are deemed as critical for high-stakes admissions decisions. 

  • A woman reading a book relaxing
    What does it mean to be fluent in English?
    投稿者 Mike Mayor
    所要時間: 3 minutes

    What do we mean by English fluency, and how can understanding competencies across the four skills provide a more realistic picture of communicative English ability?

    What is fluency?

    As someone who worked in dictionaries, the meaning of words has always interested me – and fluency is a particular case in point.

    Language learners often set themselves the goal of becoming fluent in a language. Job adverts often specify “fluent in English or Spanish” as a requirement. But what does being 'fluent' in a language actually mean? If we look in the Longman Dictionary of Contemporary English, we see that fluent means “able to speak a language very well”. Fluent speech or writing is described as “smooth and confident, with no mistakes”. In general, fluency is most often associated with spoken language – but is that the goal of all language learners? And what does being able to speak fluently show about the other language skills?

    Describing English proficiency

    Before entering the world of dictionaries, I taught English as a foreign language in France. At that time, the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR) had not yet been published and learners were described in very general terms – beginner, intermediate, advanced – with no agreed standards on what learners at each level were expected to know. As well as establishing standards, the CEFR also shifted the focus of language assessment from knowledge of grammar and vocabulary to functional competence, i.e. what can a student actually do with the language they’re learning across the four skills:

    • listening
    • reading
    • speaking
    • writing

    Interestingly, while calling out specific objectives for each skill, almost two-thirds of the information in the CEFR describes spoken language. This seems to imply that spoken fluency is indeed the most important goal for all language learners.

    Mapping out a personalized path to proficiency

    As a global publisher, Pearson English recognizes that all learners are different – in their backgrounds, learning environments and learning goals. This is why we have undertaken new research to extend the set of learning objectives contained in the CEFR to account for learners who need detailed information about their level in all four skills, not just in one (typically, that of speaking).

    No learner will be equally proficient in all four language skills – in the same way that no native speaker is equally proficient in all skills in their first language. Some of us are better at writing than speaking, and many are illiterate in their first language. A true measure of language proficiency needs to take all skills into account. Equally, not every learner of English will need to be 'fluent' in spoken communication.

    Many researchers need to read papers in English and attend conferences in English – but will only ever present and write in their first language. Is 'fluency' a good way to describe their goal? And if it isn’t, does that somehow diminish their language achievements?

    By acknowledging proficiency in individual skills – rather than catch-all terms such as 'fluent' – we gain a clearer understanding of goals and outcomes, and with this knowledge, we are in a better position to tailor learning to the individual.

    If you're looking to improve your own fluency (in any language) make sure to check out our language learning app Mondly.