教室を超えた成功の構築:批判的思考と評価

Christina Cavage
子供たちのグループは、先生と一緒にテーブルに立って、彼女が紙に何かを書き留めるのを見ていました
所要時間: 4分間

批判的思考と評価に関連する一般的な神話がいくつかあります。多くの人は、特に言語が限られているクラスでは、批判的思考を評価することは不可能だと考えています。しかし、それは可能です!ここで成功の鍵となるのは、言語スキルと認知スキルを分離できるタスクとルーブリックを作成することです。結局のところ、言語レベルが低いからといって、必ずしも生徒の批判的思考能力を反映しているわけではありません。

では、生徒が何を知っているかだけでなく、 どのように知っているか を測定するにはどうすればよいでしょうか。

批判的思考を測定する方法

まず、公式評価と非公式評価の2種類の評価を検討する必要があります。正式な評価は、タスク、レッスン、またはスキル構築活動の終了時に行われる傾向があり、通常は生徒が作成した作業に焦点を当てます。その後、非公式の評価を行います。これらは、その場でのやり取りを含む評価です。これらのタイプの評価は、批判的思考を測定する上で重要な役割を果たします。

批判的思考を教え、評価するためのヒント
再生
プライバシーとクッキー

視聴することにより、Pearsonがあなたの視聴データを1年間の間、マーケティングおよび分析のために共有することに同意したものとみなされます。クッキーを削除することで、同意を取り消すことができます。

正式な評価

評価は、生徒が生み出す最終的な作品にのみ焦点を当てるべきであるという誤解がよくあります。最終的な「製品」は紛れもなく重要であり、多くの場合、言語能力の理想的な尺度です。しかし、最終的な作品を作成するプロセスでは、生徒の批判的思考スキルが実際に発揮されているのを見ることができます。

言語的思考と批判的思考の両方を測定するルーブリックを設計する際には、言語的思考と批判的思考のどちらか一方だけに焦点を絞るようにしましょう。これらの異なるスキルを念頭に置くことで、言語スキルと批判的思考スキルを区別し、正式な評価に関してはそれらを別々に評価することができます。

言語スキルを測定するときは、ブルームの初期または基本的な認知領域をモデルとして使用します。

これらの項目を測定すると、実際には言語スキルを測定していることになります。たとえば、読書活動では、次のような質問をすることがあります。

  • 誰についての話ですか?
  • 物語の舞台はどこで?
  • ストーリーの主なアイデアは何ですか?

彼らは全体的な組織と主要な語彙を理解できますか?これらのタイプの質問は、学生の言語能力を評価します。

そして、批判的思考に関しては、ブルームの認知領域のより高度なレベルが有用なガイドを提供します。

これらのタイプの質問は、学生のメタ認知または批判的思考を評価します。

  • ストーリーにとって最も重要なキャラクターは誰ですか?
  • なぜでしょうか。
  • キャラクターの行動に同意しますか、それとも同意しませんか?
  • なぜですか、なぜそうでないのですか?

評価における言語と批判的思考の明確な分離は、各学生の両方のスキルの進歩を測定するのに役立ちます。

非公式の評価

これらの非公式の評価はどうですか?その場での評価では、批判的思考と言語スキルを明確に描写するのが難しい場合があります。

たとえば、グループワークを割り当てている場合は、学生同士のやり取りのチェックリストを保管することを検討してください。チェックリストの項目には、次のようなものがあります。

  • 誰が推論したのか?
  • 他の学生のアイデアの理由を提供したのは誰ですか?
  • 誰が比較したのか?
  • 誰が結論を出したのか?

また、生徒にチェックリストを保管してもらい、これらの質問を電子掲示板に投稿するように依頼することもできます。自己評価と同様に、これらのピアツーピア評価は、生徒に反省と気づきを促すことができます。

ルーブリックは、非公式の評価にも役立ちます。例えば、学生にエッセイの準備や執筆を依頼したとします。批判的思考を測定するために、各学生がエッセイに取り組んでいるときのアイデア出しプロセスを見ることができます。

  • 学生は考えられるすべてのトピックを見ていますか?
  • 学生が選択したオプションを選択する要因は何ですか?
  • 彼らは他のアイデアを認識していますか?

これらの質問に対する答えは、生徒が批判的に考えているかどうかを教えてくれます。

他のスキルと同様に、批判的思考の評価は公式にも非公式にも行う必要があります。プロセスと最終製品の両方を考慮する必要があります。そして、その際、言語スキルとメタ認知を区別するルーブリックを慎重に設計する必要があります。

Pearson からの他のブログ

  • A teacher writing on a whiteboard with students sat on the floor participating
    Classroom actitvies: 12 days of Christmas
    投稿者 Iram Ahmed
    所要時間: 3 minutes

    With the holiday season approaching, it’s good to add some fun into teaching to keep your students engaged and motivated. We’ve created 12 simple classroom activities and tips that you can carry out with your primary class to encourage them to be good.

    Day 1 - Santa’s watching

    Fact: Father Christmas, St. Nicholas, Sinterklaas – whatever we call him; many countries around the world have a tradition that naughty children will only receive coal, twigs or even onions. But do children always know how to be good?

    Classroom application

    Classroom tip: Catch students being good

    Watch out for good behavior and praise it when you see it. Much more effective than dealing with problems as they arise.

    Day 2 - Christmas countdown

    Fact: Advent calendars count down the days to Christmas, and for children that usually means gifts. But is the festive period all about presents?

    Classroom application

    Classroom tip: Kindness calendar

    Challenge students to carry out one act of kindness every day in December. They can plan this on a blank calendar and tick the kind acts as they complete them.

    Day 3 - Season’s greetings

    Fact: Did you know that greeting students individually at the door improves learning and engagement?

    Classroom application

    Classroom tip: Holiday password

    Have a holiday-themed password for children to give as they enter the classroom. Students choose a new password every lesson.

    Day 4 - Frosty the Snowman

    Fact: The largest snowman in the world was actually a snow-woman. Olympia was over 37 meters tall and had trees for arms.

    Classroom application

    Classroom tip: Concrete poems

    A concrete poem written in a shape that reflects the topic of the poem, for example a poem about a snowman written in the shape of a snowman. Challenge your students to write their own concrete poems about Christmas (or a current holiday for them).

    Day 5 - DIY decorations

    Fact: Chinese New Year is the most important winter festival in China. Like Christmas, one of the main activities is putting up paper decorations.

    Classroom application

    Classroom tip: Collaborative tree

    Each child draws around their hand, cuts it out and either draws a picture or writes a sentence about themselves. The whole class makes a display out of the handprints.

    Day 6 - Star students

    Fact: Stars feature in many Christmas traditions. For example, in Poland, the Christmas Eve feast only starts when the first star appears in the night sky.

    Classroom application

    Classroom tip: 2 stars and a wish

    Give focused feedback on written tasks by identifying two positive aspects of work and one area to work on. Works great for peer assessment too.

    Day 7 - Perfect presents

    Fact: Everyone loves getting presents. In Liberia, instead of Santa bringing toys, you’ll find Old Man Bayka, who walks the streets asking for gifts.

    Classroom application

    Classroom tip: My gift to the world

    Brainstorm things students can do to help make the world a better place, such as volunteering at a local charity or planting a tree. Challenge them to do one thing as a holiday gift to the world.

    Day 8 - Festive feasts

    Fact: Famous fried chicken in Japan, caterpillars in South Africa, hot tamales in Venezuela and oysters in France. Christmas dinners vary greatly as you move around the world.

    Classroom application

    Classroom tip: Recipe for success

    Students can make their own recipe for success by thinking about what they need to be successful in the new year.

    Example (to be designed to look like a child wrote it):

    • 1 cup of doing my best
    • ½ cup of ideas
    • ¼ cup of smiles
    • 2 tablespoons of teamwork
    • 3 teaspoons of listening to the teacher

    Day 9 - Holiday traditions around the world

    Fact: Festive saunas in Finland, roller skating in Venezuela and Christmas cobwebs in Ukraine – no two countries celebrate Christmas in exactly the same way.

    Classroom application

    Classroom tip: Venn diagrams

    Students choose 2 countries and research how they celebrate during wintertime. They record their findings as Venn diagrams. They record the different traditions of the two countries in the sections on the left and right. Anything they have in common goes in the middle.

    Day 10 - The excitement of Christmas

    Fact: Anticipation plays a big part in the excitement of Christmas. Will Santa come? What presents I get? Who will win the annual family game of charades?

    Classroom application

    Classroom tip: Big questions

    Start lessons by posing big questions to engage students’ natural curiosity and motivate them to find answers. Open questions work great, such as How do animals communicate? or What makes someone a hero?

    Day 11 - Holiday cheer

    Fact: Forget the Grinch, the festive season is a time for feeling good and spreading happiness.

    Classroom application

    Classroom tip: Compliment corner

    Allocate a space in the classroom as the compliment corner – a notice board or a big piece of paper. Students can write compliments to each other on sticky notes and put them on the board. Such as ‘I love the pictures you drew of your favorite hobby’ or ‘You’re so good at singing’.

    Day 12 - New Year’s resolutions

    Fact: The start of a new year is a great time to focus on self-improvement, but only 8% of people are successful in sticking to their resolutions.

    Classroom application

    Classroom tip: Self and peer reflection

    At the end of each lesson, ask students to reflect on their learning. Support students by providing sentence stems such as:

    • I learnt…
    • I enjoyed…
    • I’m good at…
    • To improve I will…
    • I didn’t understand…

    Make these activities your own and adapt them to your class. They should help you turn the lead-up to the holidays in the classroom into an exciting one for your students, and almost make them forget they're learning at the same time.

  • A student presenting in front of other students and teacher
    If AI can write in English, what should we be teaching and assessing?
    投稿者 Charlotte Guest
    所要時間: 8 minutes

    Artificial intelligence (AI) is changing how students learn, write and communicate. Tools such as ChatGPT can write essays, correct grammar, translate text and generate ideas in seconds. These tools can support learning, but they also raise important questions for teachers. How can we tell if students can use English on their own? And how can we make sure they are still developing their own ideas and thinking skills?

    These questions are becoming increasingly important in education. On 11 November 2026, England's Office for Students (OfS) announced that universities need to do more to make sure their assessments accurately measure what students know and can do. Research carried out with Advance HE found that some students were using AI to complete coursework without showing their own knowledge and skills.

    The regulator has warned that universities could face penalties if their assessments do not meet the required standards. It is encouraging institutions to use more secure assessments, including in-person exams, presentations and oral tests, where students can demonstrate their abilities without relying on AI. You can read more about the findings in The Guardian, BBC News and MLQ's coverage of the potential consequences for universities.

    However, AI is not only creating challenges. A recent University of Reading podcast about AI and creativity explored how AI could give more people access to creative activities, such as filmmaking. It also discussed the importance of teaching young people about responsible AI use and helping them understand the difference between human and AI-generated content.

    For English language teachers, these developments raise an important question: if AI can write in English and generate ideas, what should students be learning and how should we assess their progress?

  • A teacher sat at a desk helping a student in the classroom
    A magical mystery tour: How the role of English teacher is changing
    投稿者 Leonor Corradi
    所要時間: 5 minutes

    "The only constant is change”, a phrase that the philosopher Heraclitus of Ephesus is widely credited with.

    Though it may look like a paradox, actually it is not. Without becoming too philosophical, one could argue that this statement communicates the real-life truth that perpetual shifting is the single permanent rule in life. How does this apply to teaching and to the teacher’s role in particular? Let’s start our magical mystery tour.

    The first stop: the beginnings of the Communicative Approach

    Before this revolution in the world of ELT, teachers were used to being the center of the classroom – a dominant, all-controlling figure orchestrating every move. Many students were quite happy with this situation, since nothing was unexpected: their creativity and spontaneity were neither welcome nor expected. Errors were not tolerated at all and teachers were supposed to correct them and, even better, prevent them from happening.

    But soon it all changed. Teachers had two primary functions: facilitators of the communication process and independent participants within students’ groups (Breen and Candlin, 1980). No more centrality, which came as a shock to many, not because they were not ready to relinquish power, but because they were not sure how to go about this new role. What is expected from a facilitator, from a person who joins any group as another member?

    Often the answer was this one: “When you are a facilitator, if a person enters your classroom, they won’t know who the teacher is.” This led to misinterpretations of this new role. It was not about making things easier for learners, nor was it about relinquishing power and having learners decide what to do.

    This was natural. Think about a pendulum. When it’s at one end and it is moved, it does not stay in the middle but goes to the other end. Over time the pendulum reached a medium. This meant that teachers left their physical centrality, i.e. they did not stand at the front of the classroom at all times, but understood the centrality of their role in learning.

    The next stops do not follow chronological order because they overlap.

    Stop two: Task-based learning

    Our next stop: Task-based learning (Willis, 1996 and Nunan, 1989). As it could be argued that it is a framework within communicative approaches, it did not create the same uneasiness in some teachers as the Communicative Approach. The teacher’s role is more structured, especially in Willis’s framework. Teachers select and sequence tasks, monitor students as they work without correcting mistakes, yet provide scaffolding as needed and help students notice language features and become aware of how language works.

    Unlike early Communicative Language Teaching, form gets explicit attention, yet after students have been using language, i.e., after the task.

    Stop three: Project-based learning.

    Teachers move further away towards the background, acting as a coach or guide. They are expected to negotiate projects with their learners, provide scaffolding and language support as needed and assess both process and product, also encouraging self and peer assessment.

    Stop four: The Lexical Approach

    The stop: The Lexical Approach (Lewis, 1997). Teachers provide input and work toward learners noticing and discovering language features, while learners play an active, central role.

    Stop five: Teachers today

    The question goes around in society, “Will teachers be replaced by AI? Will they be necessary at all?” The answer to those questions is “No, teachers won't be replaced and will always be necessary." Why? What is there in our role that makes us unique? On the one hand, we know that we should mediate between learners and teaching materials.

    This mediation cannot be black and white, since all groups are different and, even within each group, learners have different styles and needs and are affected by different situations. It is the teacher who knows this and knows when to adapt on the spur of the moment, just by looking at their learners’ faces. Often a learner’s question or comment helps us know where they are in their learning process and the scaffolding we give takes that as the starting point.

    AI is a fantastic resource, but it is still a resource. It can help teachers generate materials and it can help learners by offering tailored information, answers to queries they may have when the teacher is not here to help, among other ideas. But the teacher has the final say before giving students AI-generated materials. The teacher’s critical reflection and mediation ensure the materials support learning.

    As explained before, the teacher is not at the front of the classroom, yet their role is central to students’ learning.

    We have come to the end of the magical mystery tour, and a question seems natural: Will AI become more intelligent and be context-sensitive in the way teachers are? We do not know. However, there have been different attempts to replace teachers since Skinner’s Teaching Machine and still, it is the teacher’s humanity that can make all the difference.