Skip to main content
Pearson+ LogoPearson+ Logo
Ch. 23 - Developmental Genetics
Klug - Concepts of Genetics  12th Edition
Klug12th EditionConcepts of Genetics ISBN: 9780135564776Not the one you use?Change textbook
Chapter 23, Problem 15

Early development depends on the temporal and spatial interplay between maternally supplied material and mRNA and the onset of zygotic gene expression. Maternally encoded mRNAs must be produced, positioned, and degraded [Surdej and Jacobs-Lorena (1998). Mol. Cell Biol. 18:2892–2900]. For example, transcription of the bicoid gene that determines anterior–posterior polarity in Drosophila is maternal. The mRNA is synthesized in the ovary by nurse cells and then transported to the oocyte, where it localizes to the anterior ends of oocytes. After egg deposition, bicoid mRNA is translated and unstable bicoid protein forms a decreasing concentration gradient from the anterior end of the embryo. At the start of gastrulation, bicoid mRNA has been degraded. Consider two models to explain the degradation of bicoid mRNA: (1) degradation may result from signals within the mRNA (intrinsic model), or (2) degradation may result from the mRNA's position within the egg (extrinsic model). Experimentally, how could one distinguish between these two models?

Verified step by step guidance
1
Step 1: Understand the two models for bicoid mRNA degradation. The intrinsic model suggests that degradation is controlled by signals within the mRNA itself, such as specific sequences or structural elements. The extrinsic model proposes that degradation is influenced by the mRNA's spatial position within the egg.
Step 2: Design an experiment to test the intrinsic model. Mutate or modify specific sequences or structural elements within the bicoid mRNA that are hypothesized to signal degradation. Introduce these modified mRNAs into the egg and observe whether their degradation pattern changes compared to the wild-type mRNA.
Step 3: Design an experiment to test the extrinsic model. Alter the spatial positioning of the bicoid mRNA within the egg, for example, by artificially localizing it to a different region (e.g., posterior instead of anterior). Observe whether the degradation pattern changes based on its new position.
Step 4: Use controls to validate the experiments. For the intrinsic model, include unmodified wild-type bicoid mRNA as a control to ensure that any observed changes are due to the mutations. For the extrinsic model, ensure that the localization technique does not inadvertently alter the mRNA's intrinsic properties.
Step 5: Analyze the results. If degradation occurs regardless of spatial position, this supports the intrinsic model. If degradation depends on the mRNA's position within the egg, this supports the extrinsic model. Combine findings from both experiments to draw conclusions about the mechanism of bicoid mRNA degradation.

Verified video answer for a similar problem:

This video solution was recommended by our tutors as helpful for the problem above.
Video duration:
1m
Was this helpful?

Key Concepts

Here are the essential concepts you must grasp in order to answer the question correctly.

Maternal Effect Genes

Maternal effect genes are genes expressed in the mother that produce mRNAs and proteins necessary for early embryonic development. These products are deposited in the egg and play crucial roles in establishing the initial conditions for development, such as body axis formation. In the case of Drosophila, the bicoid gene is a key maternal effect gene that influences anterior-posterior polarity.
Recommended video:
Guided course
03:38
Maternal Effect

mRNA Localization and Translation

mRNA localization refers to the spatial distribution of mRNA within the cell, which can affect where and when proteins are synthesized. In Drosophila, bicoid mRNA is localized to the anterior end of the oocyte, leading to localized translation of the bicoid protein. This spatial regulation is critical for establishing gradients that guide developmental processes.
Recommended video:
Guided course
07:58
Translation initiation

mRNA Degradation Mechanisms

mRNA degradation is a vital regulatory mechanism that controls gene expression levels during development. The intrinsic model suggests that specific sequences within the mRNA dictate its stability, while the extrinsic model posits that the mRNA's location influences its degradation. Understanding these mechanisms is essential for elucidating how temporal and spatial factors affect gene expression during early development.
Recommended video:
Guided course
08:39
mRNA Processing
Related Practice
Textbook Question

The homeotic mutation Antennapedia causes mutant Drosophila to have legs in place of antennae and is a dominant gain-of-function mutation. What are the properties of such mutations? How does the Antennapedia gene change antennae into legs?

828
views
Textbook Question

The Drosophila homeotic mutation spineless aristapedia (ssᵃ) results in the formation of a miniature tarsal structure (normally part of the leg) on the end of the antenna. What insight is provided by (ssᵃ) concerning the role of genes during determination?

489
views
Textbook Question

Embryogenesis and oncogenesis (generation of cancer) share a number of features including cell proliferation, apoptosis, cell migration and invasion, formation of new blood vessels, and differential gene activity. Embryonic cells are relatively undifferentiated, and cancer cells appear to be undifferentiated or dedifferentiated. Homeotic gene expression directs early development, and mutant expression leads to loss of the differentiated state or an alternative cell identity. M. T. Lewis [(2000). Breast Can. Res. 2:158–169] suggested that breast cancer may be caused by the altered expression of homeotic genes. When he examined 11 such genes in cancers, 8 were underexpressed while 3 were overexpressed compared with controls. Given what you know about homeotic genes, could they be involved in oncogenesis?

535
views
Textbook Question

Formation of germ cells in Drosophila and many other embryos is dependent on their position in the embryo and their exposure to localized cytoplasmic determinants. Nuclei exposed to cytoplasm in the posterior end of Drosophila eggs (the pole plasm) form cells that develop into germ cells under the direction of maternally derived components. R. Amikura et al. [(2001). Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. (USA) 98:9133–9138] consistently found mitochondria-type ribosomes outside mitochondria in the germ plasma of Drosophila embryos and postulated that they are intimately related to germ-cell specification. If you were studying this phenomenon, what would you want to know about the activity of these ribosomes?

625
views
Textbook Question

One of the most interesting aspects of early development is the remodeling of the cell cycle from rapid cell divisions, apparently lacking G1 and G2 phases, to slower cell cycles with measurable G1 and G2 phases and checkpoints. During this remodeling, maternal mRNAs that specify cyclins are deadenylated, and zygotic genes are activated to produce cyclins. Audic et al. [(2001). Mol. and Cell. Biol. 21:1662–1671] suggest that deadenylation requires transcription of zygotic genes. Present a diagram that captures the significant features of these findings.

452
views
Textbook Question

A number of genes that control expression of Hox genes in Drosophila have been identified. One of these homozygous mutants is extra sex combs, where some of the head and all of the thorax and abdominal segments develop as the last abdominal segment. In other words, all affected segments develop as posterior segments. What does this phenotype tell you about which set of Hox genes is controlled by the extra sex combs gene?

616
views